The Ultimate Tomato Soup Showdown: Battle of the Canned

Tomato Soup Showdown Ranking the Best and Worst Store-Bought Brands I Tried

I ranked store-bought canned tomato soup brands from worst to best.

Campbell’s Well Yes! Tomato and Sweet Basil Soup Photo by Erin McDowell/Insider

Ah, tomato soup! The ultimate comfort food that warms our souls and brings back fond childhood memories. But have you ever wondered which canned tomato soup reigns supreme? Well, fear not, fellow fashionistas, for I have embarked on a quest to find the absolute crème de la crème of canned tomato soups. Get ready for a taste test extravaganza like no other!

Tomato Soup Rumble: The Contestants

In this grand tomato soup showdown, three contenders entered the ring: Campbell’s Tomato Soup, Progresso Tomato-Basil Soup, and the luxurious Campbell’s Well Yes! Tomato-and-Sweet-Basil Soup. Each soup had its own unique flavor profile and charm, but only one could emerge victorious.

So, loosen your belts, grab a spoon, and let’s dive into this delectable tomato soup feast!

The Not-So-Classic Classic: Campbell’s Tomato Soup

Campbell’s Tomato Soup Photo by Erin McDowell/Insider

Ah, Campbell’s Tomato Soup – a staple in every pantry. This iconic soup is the perfect companion for quick lunches and grilled cheese delights. However, as I ventured into the lands of nostalgia, I encountered a challenge – the soup required a splash of water to reach its full potential.

The color was undeniably reminiscent of my youth, a vibrant orange-red reminiscent of summer sunsets. But alas, beneath its beautiful facade lurked disappointment. The soup was watery, with tiny tomato clumps conspiring to sabotage my spoonfuls. While it had a tangy and slightly sweet flavor, it lacked that extra oomph of homemade goodness. Though it may hold a special place in our hearts, it couldn’t quite compete with its fancier competitors.

The Sweet Basil Surprise: Progresso Tomato-Basil Soup

Progresso Tomato-Basil Soup Photo by Erin McDowell/Insider

With a hop, skip, and a jump, I moved on to Progresso Tomato-Basil Soup – the perfect blend of tangy tomatoes and fragrant basil. This soup came at a slightly steeper price, but oh boy, it was worth every penny!

As I heated up the soup, I noticed the small basil flecks dancing merrily within. The aroma wafting from the pot betrayed the promise of an extraordinary experience. The soup had a distinctively homemade taste, with a strong basil flavor complemented by the sweetness of tomatoes. While not as creamy as its rivals, it made up for it with its flavorful charm. This was love at first sip, and I knew that this soup would always have a special place in my heart.

The Undisputed Tomato Soup Royalty: Campbell’s Well Yes!

Campbell’s Well Yes! Tomato-and-Sweet-Basil Soup Photo by Erin McDowell/Insider

In a world filled with tomato soup contenders, there can only be one true monarch. And the crown goes to Campbell’s Well Yes! Tomato-and-Sweet-Basil Soup – the epitome of indulgence and sophistication.

Yes, this royal treat comes at a higher price, but trust me, it’s worth every dime. With its velvety texture and the perfect blend of creamy goodness, it embraces you like a warm hug on a chilly day. As I spooned it into my mouth, the sweet aroma of basil teased my senses, and the luscious tomato base offered a symphony of flavors. It was like a high-fashion ensemble on a silver spoon – perfectly balanced, savory, sweet, and acidic.

When paired with a grilled cheese sandwich, it was a match made in culinary heaven, a duet of flavors that taught my taste buds to waltz. It was a soup fit for a queen, and I gladly took my place at its regal feast.

The Verdict: Tomato Soup Dreams Do Come True

In the end, we discovered that canned tomato soup can transcend its humble origins and deliver moments of pure bliss. While Campbell’s Tomato Soup evoked nostalgia, Progresso Tomato-Basil Soup added a homemade touch to our palate. But it was Campbell’s Well Yes! Tomato-and-Sweet-Basil Soup that reigned supreme, with its extravagance and delightful flavors.

So, my dear fashion lovers, the next time you crave a bowl of tomato soup, remember that not all canned soups are created equal. Treat yourself to the luxury of Campbell’s Well Yes!, the charm of Progresso, or even bask in the nostalgic glow of Campbell’s classic. Let your taste buds embark on a marvelous journey, one spoonful at a time.

Now, go forth and conquer the tomato soup universe, my stylish comrades! And remember, fashion fades, but good taste is eternal.

Tell us: What is your favorite canned tomato soup? Share your thoughts and soup-pairing adventures in the comments below!